Skriftlig afrapportering fra mødet i Standing Committee den 12. november 2020

1
Report by President Tsereteli
Online Standing Committee Meeting, 12 November 2020
As delivered
Let me now kick-off our internal business with my report. Before I begin, I propose that any
question about the next three agenda items be grouped and taken following the update by
Secretary General MONTELLA.
ADAPTING THE WORK OF THE OSCE PA
Firstly, as you will recall, following our last meeting, we published a comprehensive report on
the Parliamentary Web Dialogues, and the work of our committees. I encourage you to continue
to refer to this document, which is a useful resource for our Delegations and our national
parliaments to share their experiences, learn about best practices, and together promote wide-
ranging responses to COVID-19 challenges.
Since we last convened online in July, the OSCE PA has transitioned to what we could call a
“hybrid” plan of activities: we have continued to organize online events, while trying to
participate in in-person meetings whenever possible.
I, for example, had the opportunity to travel to Denmark in early September to visit our
International Secretariat and meet the Danish Speaker and Foreign Minister.
Importantly, we gathered a group of OSCE experts to analyze the Organization’s and discuss
next steps.
I have since then been mostly occupied by a very busy electoral campaign in Georgia, which
in some ways is still ongoing, but I did as much as possible to stay on top of the issues and
participate in online events.
Last July, we had hoped for additional meetings in-person, for instance the Leinsweiler
seminar. However, given the health situation in many of our countries, it remains more cautious
to maintain most of our discussions online.
The Ministerial Council Meeting next month will itself take place online. And looking forward,
it remains to be seen how our Winter Meeting in 2021 will take place.
This autumn, we have strived to deploy robust delegations to fulfill our important mission to
support democratic development throughout the OSCE region.
OSCEs Parlamentariske Forsamling 2020-21
OSCE Alm.del - Bilag 5
Offentligt
2
Just a short while ago, we deployed two election observation missions to the United States and
to Georgia, totaling 77 observers. At the end of August, we also had a small mission in
Montenegro.
Despite all the complications, I want to sincerely thank you all for your continued active
engagement in our work and our mission.
I am fully aware that it can sometimes put you in an uneasy situation while our governments
and parliaments are enacting measures to curtail our citizens’ ability to travel. But we have
seen since the summer how important it is that the OSCE and the international community
remains active and engaged in the field of election observation.
THE OSCE REGION PLAGUED BY CONFLICTS AND CRISES
I have closely followed developments in Kyrgyzstan following the recent parliamentary
elections. In the months to come, it is crucial that the international community show full
support for Kyrgyzstan’s parliamentary democracy and prevent further turmoil.
This is why I think we should consider observing in some capacity the early parliamentary
elections in Kazakhstan and the early presidential election in Kyrgyzstan on 10 January 2021.
I look forward to your opinion on this.
As we are on the topic of elections, I want to congratulate all our Members who have been re-
elected in recent weeks. We are lucky to keep important Members on board.
Since the summer, we have had numerous exchanges with Members and Delegations regarding
post-election developments in Belarus. The OSCE PA has been very active on this issue.
There also we continue to monitor the situation very closely. I want to thank our colleague
from Belarus, Mr. Andrei SAVINYKH for regularly participating in our online discussions.
Despite some tough conversations, this has been a precious line of communication with the
authorities.
We are also grateful for your readiness to participate in a meeting with leading opposition
figure Svetlana Tikhanovskaya. It was extremely interesting to hear from both sides and figure
out ways out of this situation.
In addition to these exchanges, I have written to both Speakers of the Belarusian parliament to
support the offer of the OSCE chairmanship to visit Minsk and encourage an open and inclusive
dialogue. I have also offered to lead an OSCE PA delegation to visit Minsk. This offer remains
on the table.
I have encouraged Minsk to make full use of all OSCE tools to peacefully solve this crisis,
including the Moscow Mechanism. I find it very unfortunate that the OSCE expert was denied
a visa to travel to Belarus, forcing him to investigate from outside the country.
I remain convinced that it is in Belarus’s best interest to be more transparent on human
rights issues. It would have been a good opportunity to use this mechanism to build confidence
between the authorities and the opposition.
3
Dear colleagues,
What these crises reveal is that some deep-rooted tensions are being brought to the fore by
the coronavirus pandemic. In our Web Dialogues, we had highlighted increased risks for social
unrest and armed conflict.
After a serious escalation of the conflict over Nagorno-Karabakh in July, we have witnessed
full out war this autumn.
I truly hope that the agreement signed by Armenia, Azerbaijan, and the Russian Federation
earlier this week will finally offer an opportunity for long-lasting peace.
Of course it was very painful to see these military operations, but now a new process is starting.
I exchanged on several occasions with the Delegations from Armenia and Azerbaijan, and the
Speakers of parliament from these two countries, regarding military operations on the ground
and their impact on civilian lives and livelihoods.
I have been shocked by the bloodshed in the conflict zone and beyond. Given the present
situation on the ground, it is now crucial that all sides fully commit to the latest ceasefire
agreement to protect the lives of civilians.
As I noted in a statement a few days ago, the road to peace can be harder than war itself.
Although tempers are still running high, the sides must also urgently recommit to peaceful
negotiations, in good faith, to allow the safe return of internally displaced persons and refugees
and reach a long-term and comprehensive settlement.
I have firmly condemned the violent assault on President Mirzoyan. Such an attack was an
attack on democracy itself, and it is inexcusable. On behalf of the OSCE Parliamentary
Assembly, I want to wish him a full and speedy recovery.
The situation is no doubt painful for the Armenian people, it is an emotional moment, but I also
want to urge them to maintain confidence in their democratically-elected institutions to
steer their country and nation in these challenging times.
Throughout this period, I want to note the work of countries of the Minsk Group in encouraging
high-level discussions between Armenia and Azerbaijan.
As it is the case in the conflicts in Ukraine and in Georgia, we need to see discussions at the
highest level to facilitate peaceful breakthroughs that can alleviate the pain and suffering of
civilians on the ground.
This also requires some measure of mutual trust and understanding. Our Assembly continues
to encourage parliamentary dialogue, which can play an important role in rebuilding
communication lines and fostering a common future for the people of the region.
On a more hopeful note, it may be worth recalling the event we co-organized with the High
Commissioner on National Minorities on the topic of territorial autonomy. In Moldova, we can
see that despite setbacks in the settlement process – the coronavirus crisis is one of them – steps
4
taken in the right direction, through local ownership and political courage, can lead to real
progress for citizens.
And that ultimately, open and honest dialogue remains the best instrument to detect, defuse,
and overcome conflict.
CRISIS IN THE OSCE
In this turbulent context, it is damaging that we have had to endure a crisis of leadership in the
OSCE. The inability to reach an agreement on the term extensions of the OSCE’s top four
executive positions, or even to agree on an interim solution, left a vacuum that has damaged
our collective security.
Since July, the Albanian Chairmanship has worked diligently to interview suitable candidates
for all four positions. Some good friends of the OSCE PA are candidates for these positions.
Let me salute Ditmir BUSHATI, who is online with us today, and is a candidate to become the
new OSCE Representative on Media Freedom. A former Bureau Member, Matteo MECACCI,
is candidate for Director of ODIHR, while Amb. ABDRAKHMANOV from Kazakhstan is
candidate for High Commissioner on National Minorities – many of us have had the pleasure
to work with him as Ambassador to the OSCE and as Foreign Minister. We wish them all luck!
In the meantime, together with Secretary General MONTELLA, we have worked to develop
an OSCE PA contribution to solving the crisis in the OSCE.
When I mentioned our recent discussion in Denmark, it was precisely dedicated to this. Roberto
will brief you in greater detail on this project, but I will give you some broad lines of our
analysis.
We first need to realize that the leadership vacuum is not a crisis in itself – it is another symptom
of the long-standing and widespread crisis that continues to affect the OSCE, which is largely
caused by a total lack of interest for the OSCE at a political level in the vast majority of
participating States.
This crisis is purely political: the ability to rapidly deploy the Special Monitoring Mission in
Ukraine proves that the OSCE can be operational when there is political will.
Outspoken support for the OSCE’s mediation capabilities in Belarus and in the conflict over
Nagorno-Karabakh also underline this. As recent months have demonstrated, the OSCE
garners attention at the highest political level especially in times of crisis.
In order to refocus attention on the OSCE, we must therefore continue to demonstrate what
participating States gain their from membership.
In this effort, it is crucial that together we reinforce multilateralism and maintain the work
of the OSCE at the top of our domestic and international agendas in our home parliaments,
in conversations with governments and foreign ministers, and in our exchanges with the
international community.
5
It is only through greater co-operation that we can together deal with the COVID-19 crisis,
and all the other major challenges we have to face: radicalization and terrorism – which in
recent weeks have struck France and Austria -, the migrant crisis, or climate change.
I believe it is also important for our Assembly to be able to rely on the goodwill and
experience of former Members, who may have moved on to other positions in government,
in non-governmental organizations, in academia, or the private sector.
On several occasions, I have shared with you our ideas on how to involve these people more
actively in our work.
Finally, and as part of our contribution to revitalizing the OSCE, this year has encouraged us
to take a deep look at our Rules of Procedure. This is needed not only to close loopholes
that have been exposed by the pandemic, but also to continue our efforts to modernize our
working practices and make our work – and the use of your time – more effective. I look
forward to the report by Vice-President BOWNESS on this issue later in our agenda.
This concludes my report.
As indicated earlier, we can group comments and questions after the report by the Secretary
General.


Timeline for the Deliberation of Emergency Provisions
Presented by Vice President Lord Bowness at the Online Standing Committee Meeting, 12 November 2020
1. Rules for emergency situations to be discussed by the President's Advisory Group and by the upcoming
Bureau meeting on 2 December, and then voted by the Standing Committee in February. The aim of the
emergency rules is exactly to ensure that decisions such as the election of officers can take place regularly
in July 2021 regardless of the format of the Annual Session, and that there is no repetition of this year's
freezing of the Bureau.
2. Then, all the other revisions can be voted upon, with more time, at the next Annual Session.
OSCEs Parlamentariske Forsamling 2020-21
OSCE Alm.del - Bilag 5
Offentligt


1
Report by Treasurer Juel-Jensen
Online Standing Committee Meeting, 12 November 2020
As delivered
Thank you President!
Dear colleagues,
Nice to “see” you and greetings from Denmark.
I very much thank President Tsereteli for calling this meeting of the Standing Committee. It is very
necessary for our Assembly that we maintain our engagement despite the current circumstances.
Hopefully meetings in person will happen soon.
And thanks also to Secretary General Montella and all his staff in Copenhagen and Vienna for
maintaining the Assembly so active and engaged in these difficult times.
I will be very brief. I repeat my motto: TIME IS MONEY
I am very happy that the Standing Committee approved the budget for this financial year that started
on October First: Thank you for your support.
The Assembly´s current budget reflects the minimum basic needs of the Assembly responding to the
measures to respond to the COVID-19 pandemic.
As you know the Assembly’s budget for this year reflects the accrual of the amounts saved in our
current budget as an extra contribution from the OSCE PA International Secretariat to the OSCE PA
overall budget, thus automatically reducing the amounts of all national delegations’ annual
contributions. Let me underline that this is a very exceptional measure and next year we will have
to go back to the standard procedures and national contributions will therefore be higher.
But we have a long period before us, and I thank all Delegations that have made their contributions
available.
OSCEs Parlamentariske Forsamling 2020-21
OSCE Alm.del - Bilag 5
Offentligt
2
President, colleagues,
Our external auditor in Copenhagen – Pernille Dupont - will soon finalise preparing the audit for the
last fiscal year 2019-2020 that just concluded. I will be able to report on the audit to the Bureau in
December and, in accordance with the Rules of Procedure, I will also report to you in Vienna at our
Winter Meeting.
I can advance that all indications suggest that we will once again be given a positive assessment for
our financial management. It is also a pleasure to advance that the OSCE Parliamentary Assembly
continues to remain within our approved budget.
I conclude by stressing the words of our President: This Parliamentary Assembly has always
functioned – and continues to function – in an extremely cost-effective and efficient way, thanks to
the continuous support, commitment, and solidarity of all national delegations.
Thank you.