Orientering om den fremtidige procedure for behandlingen af visse ansøgninger om dansk indfødsret omfattet af statsløsekonventionen, fra udlændinge- og integrationsministeren
Tilhører sager:
- Hovedtilknytning: IFU alm. del (Bilag 152)
Aktører:
Brev af 16. august 2018 til UNHCR
https://www.ft.dk/samling/20171/almdel/IFU/bilag/152/1935207.pdf
Indfødsretsudvalget 2017-18 IFU Alm.del Bilag 152 Offentligt
Brev af 28. august 2018 fra UNHCR
https://www.ft.dk/samling/20171/almdel/IFU/bilag/152/1935206.pdf
Indfødsretsudvalget 2017-18 IFU Alm.del Bilag 152 Offentligt
Orientering om den fremtidige procedure for behandlingen af visse ansøgninger om dansk indfødsret omfattet af statsløsekonventionen
https://www.ft.dk/samling/20171/almdel/IFU/bilag/152/1935204.pdf
Ministeren Side 1/2 5. september 2018 Indfødsret Slotsholmsgade 10 1216 København K Tel. 6198 4000 Mail uim@uim.dk Web www.uim.dk CVR-nr. 36977191 Sags nr. 2018 - 1659 Akt-id 518886 Indfødsretsudvalget Folketinget Christiansborg 1240 København K Ansøgninger om dansk indfødsret ved naturalisation fra ansøgere omfattet af statsløsekonventionen, som af PET vurderes at kunne være til fare for landets sikkerhed, eller som er sigtet eller tiltalt for forbrydelser mod landets sikkerhed eller for en forbrydelse, der kan medføre en fængselstraf på 5 år eller derover Danmark har tiltrådt statsløsekonventionen, hvilket betyder, at visse statsløse personer har krav på dansk statsborgerskab, hvis konventionens betingelser er opfyldt. Regeringen ønsker dog ikke at meddele dansk statsborgerskab til statsløse omfat- tet af statsløsekonventionen, hvis Politiets Efterretningstjeneste PET vurderer, at de pågældende kan være til fare for landets sikkerhed, eller hvis de pågældende aktuelt er sigtet eller tiltalt for forbrydelser mod landets sikkerhed eller en forbry- delse, der kan medføre en fængselstraf på 5 år eller derover. Regeringen har derfor siden februar 2018 været i dialog med UNHCR om statslø- sekonventionen og muligheden for – inden for konventionens rammer – at udsæt- te behandlingen af sager af den nævnte karakter. UNHCR er enig med regeringen i, at det ikke vil være i strid med statsløsekonven- tionen at udsætte behandlingen af en ansøgning om dansk statsborgerskab i de tilfælde, hvor PET vurderer, at den pågældende ansøger kan være til fare for lan- dets sikkerhed, eller hvor ansøgeren er sigtet eller tiltalt for en forbrydelse, der kan medføre en fængselsstraf på 5 år eller derover. Udlændinge- og Integrationsministeriet vil derfor fremover udsætte sagens be- handling i disse tilfælde. Ministeriet vil ikke i udgangspunktet forelægge ansøg- ningen for Folketingets Indfødsretsudvalg. Den nye procedure udsætter alene tidspunktet for, hvornår en person modtager en afgørelse i sin sag om ansøgning om dansk statsborgerskab ved naturalisation. Udsættelsen sker med henvisning til, at ansøgeren kan være til fare for landets sikkerhed, eller at ansøgeren er sigtet eller tiltalt for en forbrydelse mod landets sikkerhed eller for en forbrydelse, der kan medføre en fængselstraf på 5 år eller derover. Indfødsretsudvalget 2017-18 IFU Alm.del Bilag 152 Offentligt Side 2/2 Den nye procedure afskærer ikke statsløse personer fra at søge om dansk stats- borgerskab, og proceduren indebærer ikke, at statsløse personer meddeles afslag på deres ansøgning i strid med statsløsekonventionens bestemmelser. Udlændinge- og Integrationsministeriet vil løbende og af egen drift – i forbindelse med regeringens halvårlige lovforslag om meddelelse af dansk indfødsret– følge op på, om ansøgeren fortsat vurderes at kunne være til fare for landets sikkerhed, eller om ansøgeren fortsat er sigtet eller tiltalt i en relevant straffesag. Såfremt Udlændinge- og Integrationsministeriet efter en konkret vurdering finder, at der bør træffes afgørelse i sagen af hensyn til omfanget af den samlede sags- behandlingstid, jf. i den forbindelse statsborgerretskonventionens artikel 10 om behandling af ansøgninger om indfødsret inden for en rimelig tidsfrist, vil ministe- riet forelægge sagen for Folketingets Indfødsretsudvalg uden indstilling, men med en redegørelse for de relevante konventionsmæssige forpligtelser. Det vil i disse tilfælde være op til Folketingets Indfødsretsudvalg at afgøre, om der skal træffes afgørelse i sagen, eller om sagen fortsat bør udsættes på en afklaring af ansøgerens forhold. Regeringen har som anført ovenfor drøftet denne nye procedure med UNHCR, der har oplyst, at UNHCR er enig med regeringen i, at proceduren er i overensstem- melse med statsløsekonventionen. Til Indfødsretsudvalgets orientering vedlægges Udlændinge- og Integrationsmini- steriets brev og notat af 16. august 2018 vedrørende den nye procedure til UNHCR samt UNHCR’s svar herpå af 28. august 2018. Inger Støjberg / Nicolai Holm Larsen
Notat af 16. august 2018 til UNHCR
https://www.ft.dk/samling/20171/almdel/IFU/bilag/152/1935205.pdf
Brief Side 1/10 16 August 2018 Indfødsret (Nationality Division) Slotsholmsgade 10 DK-1216 Copenhagen K Tel. 6198 4000 E-mail: uim@uim.dk Web www.uim.dk CVR no. 36977191 Case no. 2018 - 1659 Akt-id 510273 Processing of applications for Danish citizenship by naturalisation from appli- cants covered by the UN Convention on the Reduction of Statelessness of 1961 (the 1961 Convention), and who PET (the Danish Security and Intelligence Ser- vice) assesses as a potential threat to national security, or who are charged or indicted for offences against national security or a criminal offence that can result in imprisonment of 5 years or more 1. Introduction and background Under the 1961 Convention, Denmark is obliged to grant citizenship to persons who are born in Denmark and covered by the 1961 Convention, provided that the conditions of the convention are met. In principle, this also applies for persons who the Danish Security and Intelligence Service (PET) assesses as a potential threat to national security. The government does not wish to grant Danish citizenship to stateless persons covered by the 1961 Convention if PET assesses that the person in question is a potential threat to national security, or if the person in question is currently charged or indicted for offences against national security or a criminal offence that can result in imprisonment of 5 years or more. The government notes in this connection that the 1961 Convention does not in itself oblige the contracting states to grant citizenship to an applicant covered by the convention immediately upon the submitted application. In this regard, the convention does not contain a requirement of case processing within a defined time. Furthermore, in the assessment of the government, it would not contravene the object and purpose of the 1961 Convention or the considerations on which the Convention is based to postpone the assessment of whether an applicant is entitled to the granting of Danish citizenship under the Convention, to the extent that such postponement can be objectively justified. Therefore, going forward, the government will postpone the processing of appli- cations from stateless persons covered by the 1961 Convention for as long as PET assesses that the applicant is a potential threat to national security, or as long as the charge or indictment is upheld. The government will, every six months and on Indfødsretsudvalget 2017-18 IFU Alm.del Bilag 152 Offentligt Page 2/10 its own initiative, in every single case ensure that there is still an objectively justi- fied basis for a postponement, in addition to other foreseen safeguards based on existing oversight mechanisms. It is the understanding of the government that the UNHCR concurs with the view of the government that this new approach is in line with the 1961 Convention. The a kg ou d fo the go e e t’s app oa h to this issue is fu the des i ed in this brief. Section 2 of this brief contains a review of the Danish citizenship system. Section 3 contains a description of the mechanisms for oversight of PET. Section 4 presents a e ie of De a k’s ele a t i te atio al o ligatio s elati g to itize ship. Section 5 then provides a detailed explanation of how the government will now handle cases of the above-mentioned nature, implementing the approach of postponing the final consideration of whether citizenship is to be granted. 2. The Danish citizenship system Pursuant to section 44 (1) of the Danish Constitution, no alien can obtain citizen- ship by means other than law (naturalisation). Thus, the Danish Parliament de- cides who is to be granted Danish citizenship. The conditions for obtaining Danish citizenship by naturalisation are outlined in Circular no. 10873 of 13 October 2015 on Naturalisation. Traditionally, the guide- lines for naturalisation have been based on political agreements concluded by a majority in the Parliament. The political agreement sets out the guidelines for the drafting of a bill on the granting of citizenship. Deviation from these guidelines is only permitted with the support of a parliamentary majority, which in practice ea s a ajo it of the Da ish Pa lia e t’s Natu alisatio Co ittee. Questio s regarding dispensation from the provisions of the Circular and the interpretation of matters of doubt are always submitted to the Committee. Dispensation can o l e g a ted if a ajo it of the Co ittee’s e e s ote i fa ou . In relation to the processing of applications for naturalisation, the Nationality Division of the Ministry of Immigration and Integration serves a secretariat func- tion for the Danish Parliament (Naturalisation Committee), reviewing on behalf of the Parliament whether applicants meet the conditions for obtaining Danish citi- zenship outlined in the Circular. As with other matters regarding immigrants, this form of case processing means that the minister does not deal with individual cases, nor is the minister presented with briefs on practice or the like. The minis- ter holds the political responsibilit fo the offi e’s o k u de the Mi ist of Immigration and Integration, but the Nationality Division has always performed a dual role: it is an ordinary case processing office at the ministry, while also serving Page 3/10 a secretariat function in relation to the Da ish Pa lia e t’s Natu alisatio Com- mittee. Pursuant to the Circular, there are special cases in which an application for Danish itize ship ust e su itted to the Da ish Pa lia e t’s Natu alisatio Co it- tee for consideration of dispensation from the applicable guidelines. The Danish Pa lia e t’s Natu alisatio Co ittee holds sole po e to de ide hethe a applicant for Danish citizenship can be granted dispensation from one or more of the conditions in the Circular. Section 21 of the Circular prescribes that the cases of persons who are assessed as a potential threat to national security must be submitted to the Naturalisation Committee. The Mi ist of I ig atio a d I teg atio ’s su issio to the Da ish Pa lia- e t’s Natu alisatio Co ittee does not include a recommendation regarding the Co ittee’s de isio o g a ti g dispe satio to the appli a t i uestio . The only exception to this practice is in the case of persons assessed as a potential threat to national security, in which case the submission includes a recommenda- tion from the Minister of Justice suggesting exclusion for a specified period of time, see below. 2.1. Persons who are assessed as a potential threat to national security Prior to the proposal of a bill on the granting of citizenship, PET is notified of all persons included in the bill so that PET can assess whether any of the included persons are a potential threat to national security. If PET assesses that a person is a potential threat to national security, the person in question – on the recommendation of the Minister of Justice and after prior su issio to the Da ish Pa lia e t’s Natu alisatio Co ittee – will typically be removed from the bill. In this process, the Ministry of Immigration and Integration receives notification from the Ministry of Justice that a named person is assessed by PET as a potential threat to national security. No detailed background for this assessment is included in the notification. On the basis of the information from the Ministry of Justice, the Ministry of Immi- g atio a d I teg atio su its the ase to the Da ish Pa lia e t’s Natu alisatio Committee with a recommendation to exclude the person in question from inclu- sion in the bill on the granting of citizenship for a specified period of time. In prac- tice, PET generally recommends exclusion of the applicant for a period of 5 years. The case is submitted confidentially to the Committee and is not submitted with the name, but only with information about nationality, place of birth, year of birth and details about the issuance of a Danish residence permit. Page 4/10 Cases in which a person is covered by the 1961 Convention and assessed by PET as a potential threat to national security are also submitted to the Danish Parlia- e t’s Natu alisatio Co ittee fo the Co ittee’s de isio o hethe the applicant will remain listed in the bill, irrespective of the assessment by PET that the person in question is a potential threat to national security. The submission is provided without a recommendation on exclusion from citizenship, as the Com- mittee is informed of the relevant convention obligations. 3. Controls on the Danish Security and Intelligence Service (PET) .1. Citize s’ a ess to i sight i to i for atio Pursuant to section 12 (1) of the Danish Security and Intelligence Service Act, a physical or legal person does not have the right to insight into information that PET processes about said person or the right to insight into whether PET is pro- cessing information about said person. However, under section 12 (2) of the Danish Security and Intelligence Service Act, PET may grant full or partial insight into information mentioned in section 12 (1) of the Act, if exceptional circumstances justify such insight. The rejection of an application for citizenship due to a threat assessment by PET will not in itself justi- fy full or partial insight. Additionally, section 13 (1) of the Danish Security and Intelligence Service Act states that a physical or legal person can request that the Danish Intelligence Oversight Board (the Oversight Board) investigate whether the service is pro- cessing information about the person in question without justification. The Over- sight Board ensures that this is not the case, and then informs the person in ques- tion accordingly. The procedural history of the Danish Security and Intelligence Service Act states that the notification by the Oversight Board must only imply that no unjustified processing of information about the person in question is taking place. Thus it must not be expressly or implicitly stated that information has been processed or that justified processing of information is taking place. Section 13 (3) states that, if justified by exceptional circumstances, the Oversight Board can order PET to grant full or partial insight into information mentioned in section 12 (1). The order is legally binding for PET. The procedural history further states that section 13 (2) – now section 13 (3) – of the Danish Security and Intelligence Service Act is intended to serve as a safety valve that supplements section 12 (2) of the Act. Furthermore, it also states that the fact that PET has processed information about a person, etc. without justifica- tion does not in itself constitute sufficient grounds for the Oversight Board to order PET to grant insight into information about the person in question under Page 5/10 the current section 13 (3). Regarding the nature of exceptional circumstances that can justify an order to PET, refer to the explanatory memorandum on section 12 of the Danish Security and Intelligence Service Act. 3.2. The Danish Intelligence Oversight Board The Danish Intelligence Oversight Board is a special independent monitoring body that was established on 1 January 2014. It is stated in the Danish Security and Intelligence Service Act that the president of the Oversight Board must be a judi- cially appointed High Court Judge. Acting in response to complaints or on its own initiative, the Oversight Board en- sures that PET processes information about physical or legal persons in accord- ance with the Danish Security and Intelligence Service Act and the rules issued pursuant thereto, see section 18 of the Danish Security and Intelligence Service Act. The Oversight Board must ensure that PET complies with the rules of the Act on: - procurement of information, including gathering and collection; - internal processing of information, including deadlines for the deletion of information; - transfer of information, including to the Danish Defence Intelligence Service (FE) and to other Danish administrative authorities, private recipients, for- eign authorities and international organisations; and - prohibition of processing information about physical persons residing in Denmark solely on the basis of their legal political activity. The Oversight Board thus inspects, among other things, whether PET is processing information about a person without justification. The task of the O e sight Boa d is to pe fo he ks of the legalit of PET’s p o- cessing of information about physical and legal persons in accordance with the law. Thus the Oversight Board does not check whether PET performs its tasks in an expedient manner, including how the service prioritises its operative and intel- ligence resources, as this is based on a police assessment. Therefore, the Over- sight Boa d a ot e ie PET’s assess e t of hethe , fo e a ple, a pe so constitutes a threat to national security, see chapters 12 and 13 of the Danish Criminal Code. The Oversight Board can check whether the information that con- stitutes the basis for the assessment has been processed in accordance with the Danish Security and Intelligence Service Act. The Oversight Board notifies the Minister of Justice of matters about which the minister, in the view of the Oversight Board, should be aware. If, in exceptional cases, PET decides not to follow a recommendation in a statement from the Over- sight Board, see section 19 (1) of the Danish Security and Intelligence Service Act, Page 6/10 PET must inform the Oversight Board accordingly and, without undue delay, sub- mit the case to the Minister of Justice for a decision, see section 19 (2) and (3) of the Danish Security and Intelligence Service Act. The Oversight Board can demand that PET provide all information and all materi- als of sig ifi a e fo the O e sight Boa d’s a ti ities, see section 20 (1) of the Danish Security and Intelligence Service Act. The Oversight Board can also require written statements from PET regarding factual and legal matters of significance fo the O e sight Boa d’s a ti ities, see se tio 0 of the Danish Security and Intelligence Service Act. 3.3. Oversight by the Danish Parliament The Da ish Pa lia e t’s I tellige e Se i es Co ittee ISC has the pa lia en- tary insight into PET. The Committee must be informed of significant circumstanc- es relating to: security, foreign policy issues, matters of importance to the activi- ties of the intelligence services, and the content of certain guidelines on the activi- ties of the intelligence services prior to the issuances of said guidelines. ISC must be given a detailed annual orientation on the activities of PET. The gov- ernment is obliged, upon request by ISC, to give the Committee information about the activities of PET, including statistical information, and the Committee can re- quire that the head of PET participate in Committee meetings. The annual report that PET is required to issue pursuant to the Danish Security and Intelligence Ser- vice Act must be submitted to the Committee before it is made public. ISC can request that PET provide a report on matters pertaining to the activities of PET, including the background for threat assessments that have resulted in the rejection of applications for citizenship. However, the Committee does not have the power to revise a threat assessment. 3.4. Oversight by the Ministry of Justice The Ministry of Justice performs oversight of PET, and the intelligence service is subject to the instructions of the minister. The head of PET reports directly to the Minister of Justice, even though PET is organisationally under the auspices of the Danish National Police. In this regard, it is incumbent upon the head of PET to always keep the Ministry of Justice directly informed about all matters of importance pertaining to the coun- t ’s i te al se u it a d ge e all o all atte s of importance within the activi- ties of the intelligence service, including as regards all important individual cases, see section 1 (1) (4) of the Danish Security and Intelligence Service Act. Section 2 of the Danish Security and Intelligence Service Act further states that PET must submit an annual report on its activities to the Minister of Justice and Page 7/10 that this report must be made public. The report must provide general infor- atio o PET’s o di a a ti ities a d ust i lude a ge e al e ie of PET’s acti ities du i g the ea , as ell as the se i e’s e o o i a d ad i ist ati e circumstances. . De ark’s i ter atio al o ligatio s 4.1. UN Convention on the Reduction of Statelessness of 30 August 1961 In 1977, Denmark ratified the UN Convention on the Reduction of Statelessness of 30 August 1961 (the 1961 Convention). Pursuant to article 1 of the 1961 Convention, member states are obliged to grant citizenship to stateless persons who are born in the country, either at birth in accordance with law, or by application. Article 1 (2) of the convention states that a contracting state can make the granting of citizenship subject to one or more listed conditions, including: that the person has always been stateless; that the application eligibility window must start no later than the age of 18 and must end no earlier than at the age of 21; that the person has had permanent residence for a designated period of time not exceeding 5 years immediately prior to applica- tion, or 10 years in total; and that the person has not been found guilty of an of- fence against national security or sentenced to imprisonment of 5 years or more for a criminal offence. In accordance with the 1961 Convention and pursuant to the Circular on Naturali- sation, applicants who were born stateless in Denmark are listed in a bill on the granting of citizenship without being subject to the normal conditions for naturali- sation. However, the following conditions must be met: 1) The applicant must have permanent residence in the country. 2) The application must be submitted from the age of 18 and before the age of 21. 3) The applicant must have had permanent residence in Denmark for 5 years immediately before the submission of the application or 8 years in total. 4) The applicant must not have been found guilty of any offence against na- tional security or sentenced to imprisonment of 5 years or more for a crim- inal offence. 5) The applicant has always been stateless. Furthermore, the applicant must submit a sworn declaration that the applicant has not be found guilty of any offence against national security or sentenced to imprisonment of 5 years or more for a criminal offence. 4.2. The European Convention on Nationality Page 8/10 In 2002, Denmark ratified the European Convention on Nationality of 6 November 1997 (Convention on Nationality). The Convention on Nationality compiles, supplements and expands upon the in- te atio al o e tio s o itize ship that e isted at the ti e of the o e tio ’s adoption, and its aims include the establishment of international principles and standards in this area. Pursuant to article 10 of the Convention on Nationality, all contracting states must ensure that applications for acquisition of citizenship in the country are processed within a reasonable time. The explanatory report on the Convention on Nationality only provides limited contributions to a detailed understanding of the scope of article 10. It follows from the explanatory report that the determination of whether an application is processed within a reasonable time must be made in the light of all relevant cir- cumstances. 4.3. Access to judicial review In its judgment of 13 September 2013, the Supreme Court stated that Denmark has acceded to a number of international conventions that may affect the pro- cessing of applications for citizenship or for the granting of citizenship. According to the Supreme Court, these international obligations are to be complied with by Parliament and its Naturalisation Committee when assessing if Danish citizenship is to be granted to an applicant. An applicant who has not been included in a bill on the granting of citizenship can thus have the courts review if these internation- al obligations have been violated and if the applicant for that reason is entitled to compensation. 5. The feasibility of postponing consideration of specific applications 5.1. Legal assessment In the assessment of the Ministry of Immigration and Integration, the 1961 Con- vention does not in itself oblige the contracting states to grant citizenship to an applicant covered by the convention in immediate connection with the submitted application. In this regard, the ministry notes that the convention does not con- tain a requirement of case processing within a defined time. Furthermore, in the assessment of the Ministry of Immigration and Integration, it would not contravene the purpose of the 1961 Convention or the considerations on which the convention is based to postpone the assessment of whether an ap- plicant is entitled to the granting of Danish citizenship under the convention, to the extent that such postponement can be objectively justified, for example on the basis that the applicant in question is a potential threat to national security, or Page 9/10 that the applicant is currently charged or indicted for offences against national security or a criminal offence that may result in imprisonment of 5 years or more. Such postponement of the assessment of whether an applicant is entitled to the granting of Danish citizenship under the convention will not contravene the Con- vention on Nationality as long as the specific case, following an overall assess- ment, can be processed within a reasonable time. In this connection, it must be dee ed of g eat i po ta e that a o t a ti g state’s i tellige e se i e should have the opportunity to assess the applicant in question, and that such assess- ment can be difficult and time consuming, given the general and complex nature of existing threats. Furthermore, it must also be deemed of great importance that a o t a ti g state’s poli e a d p ose uti g autho it should ha e the oppo tu it to investigate and conduct a criminal case against such applicants before the con- tracting state makes a decision to grant them citizenship. It is on this background that the Ministry of Immigration and Integration assesses that that it ill ot o t a e e De a k’s i te atio al o ligatio s, i ludi g the 1961 Convention, to postpone the assessment of whether an applicant covered by the 1961 Convention is entitled to inclusion in a bill on the granting of citizenship in cases where PET assesses that the applicant is a potential threat to national security. Furthermore, it would not contravene the 1961 Convention to postpone such cases if the applicant is currently charged with or indicted for offences against national security or a criminal offence that can result in imprisonment of 5 years or more. In the assessment of the Ministry of Immigration and Integration, the postpone- ment of the assessment of whether an applicant is to be rejected or included in a bill on the granting of citizenship can be extended for as long as PET assesses that the applicant is a potential threat to national security, or as long as the charge or indictment against the applicant is upheld. However, it is a requirement that the postponement does not result in the applicant not receiving a decision within a reasonable time. 5.2. New procedure for the processing of applications from stateless persons covered by the 1961 Convention Going forward, based on the above assessment – in cases where PET assesses that an applicant covered by the 1961 Convention is a potential threat to national se- curity, or in cases where the applicant is charged or indicted for offences against national security or a criminal offence that can result in imprisonment of 5 years o o e, a d he e the appli a t othe ise eets the o e tio ’s o ditio s for citizenship – the Ministry of Immigration and Integration will postpone the processing of the case. Page 10/10 In these cases, the Ministry of Immigration and Integration will not issue a rejec- tio of the appli a t’s appli atio , a d, as a ge e al ule, the i ist ill ot submit the appli atio to the Da ish Pa lia e t’s Natu alisatio Co ittee. To ensure that the necessary basis for postponement of the case remains in force in instances where PET has assessed that the applicant is a potential threat to national security, the Ministry of Immigration and Integration will every six months, and on its own initiative, request a renewed PET assessment of the appli- cant. This will be done in connection with the two semi-annual bills on the grant- ing of citizenship, which are typically presented to the Danish Parliament in April and October. In cases where the applicant is charged or indicted for offences against national security or a criminal offence that can result in imprisonment of 5 years or more, the ministry will also, on its own initiative, confirm that the charge or indictment is still in force. If, based on a concrete assessment, the Ministry of Immigration and Integration finds that a decision should be made in the case in view of the overall case pro- cessing time, the ministry will su it the ase to the Da ish Pa lia e t’s Natu al- isation Committee without a recommendation, but with a report on the relevant convention obligations. In these cases, it will be up to the Danish Parliament to determine whether a deci- sion is to be made in the case, or if the decision should remain postponed subject to la ifi atio of the appli a t’s i u sta es. In conclusion, it is important to emphasise that this new procedure only post- pones the time at which a person will receive a decision regarding their applica- tion for Danish citizenship. The postponement is carried out with reference to the assessment that the applicant is a potential threat to national security, or the fact that the applicant is charged or indicted for offences against national security or an offence that can result in imprisonment of 5 years or more. Thus, the new pro- cedure does not exclude stateless persons from applying for Danish citizenship and it does not lead to rejections of applications of stateless persons in violation of the provisions of the 1961 Convention. Finally, the applicants in question may have the courts review whether the relevant international obligations have been violated and whether the applicants for that reason are entitled to compensation.